Proton Mail vs Gmail: Proton Scribe or smart features
Proton Mail is the better inbox if you want AI kept away from your mail. Proton Scribe writes drafts without training on your mailbox. Gmail suits you better if free storage matters most. Its smart features use your mail content and start off in Europe.
Some buttons on this site can earn us a commission. You pay the same price.
This button can earn us a commission. You pay the same price.
Proton Mail
Encrypted email without ads, which Proton itself cannot read
This button can earn us a commission. You pay the same price.
From $3.99/mo, checked
Gmail
Google's free inbox, with an AI setting worth switching off.
From $1.99/mo, checked
Prices last checked on
| Feature | Proton Mail | Gmail |
|---|---|---|
| AI protection | ||
| AI feature | Proton Scribe and Proton Sentinel | Smart features in Gmail, Chat and Meet |
| What it does | Scribe drafts your email. Sentinel blocks a takeover of your account. | Suggests replies, sorts your inbox and adds package cards. |
| Free or which plan | Scribe comes with Duo, Family, Visionary and Lifetime. Not in Proton Free. | Free with every Google account. |
| What happens to your input | Prompts are encrypted in transit and deleted right after use. Local mode never leaves your device. | Your mail content feeds the smart features. In the EEA they start switched off. |
| Switching it off | Nothing to switch off. Scribe is an extra you choose to add. | Settings, See all settings, General, Smart features. |
| Scam and phishing checks | Scribe does not read incoming mail. Sentinel only guards sign-ins. | Gmail identifies phishing emails automatically and warns you. |
| What each provider says about its own AI feature. | ||
| Our score | 4.4 / 5 | n/a |
| Price | From $3.99/mo | From $1.99/mo |
| Free plan | ||
| Best for | Anyone leaving an ad-funded inbox | Anyone comparing Gmail to encrypted email |
| Visit Proton Mail This button can earn us a commission. You pay the same price. | Visit Gmail | |
Our verdict
Proton Mail is the better choice if you want your mail kept away from the company that stores it. Zero-access encryption locks Proton out of your messages on every plan. No ads are built on what you write. Gmail encrypts your mail in transit with TLS.
The setup where not even Google can open a message is client-side encryption. Google offers that to work and school accounts. On AI the difference is who decides. Scribe is an extra you add yourself and Proton says it does not train on your inbox. The smart features in Gmail use your mail content.
In the EEA they start switched off. Free storage is where Gmail wins. A Google account holds 15 GB across Gmail, Drive and Photos. Proton Free stops at 1 GB with one address. Mail Plus is the paid step up. A year costs $47.88 and works out to $3.99 a month.
“A sensible pick if you want email that is never scanned for ads. Encryption covers every plan, the free one included. Proton Scribe is the AI writing help and it is not part of Proton Free. The free plan also fills up fast with 1 GB and one address.”Editorial team, on Proton Mail
Frequently asked questions
Does Google read my Gmail emails?
Not to show you ads, according to Google. Its support page says "We will not scan or read your Gmail messages to show you ads". Your mail content does feed the smart features of Gmail. That covers suggested replies, the sorting of your inbox and the package cards. In the European Economic Area, the UK, Switzerland and Japan those features start switched off.
How do I turn off AI training in Gmail?
With one switch in your own settings. Open Settings and then See all settings. Go to the General tab and find the Smart features section. Turn off the box for smart features in Gmail, Chat and Meet. A separate switch covers Workspace and other Google products. In the EEA both start off already, so check before you change anything.
Does Proton Mail use AI on my emails?
Only where you pay for it. Proton Scribe is the AI writing assistant and it is missing from Proton Free. Duo, Family, Visionary and Lifetime include it. Other paid plans buy it as an add-on. Proton says prompts sent to its servers are "encrypted in transit and deleted immediately after use". In local mode the model runs on your own device.
How much does Proton Mail cost compared to Gmail?
Both start free. Proton Free gives you 1 GB and one address. Every Google account gets up to 15 GB shared across Gmail, Drive and Photos. Proton Mail Plus costs $4.99 month to month, or $47.88 for a year, which saves you $12. Paying Google gets you more room and not more privacy. Google One Basic starts at $1.99 a month.